Tesla's customer allegiance is waning in the United States, with trade-ins from owners increasing by 250% compared to last year.

• Loyalty to the Tesla brand is breaking down.
• Nationwide, trade-ins of Tesla vehicles rose by 250% compared to the previous year in March.
• Anticipated used prices are likely to start dropping due to higher availability in the upcoming months.

If your go-to burger place suddenly let go of its entire cooking team, transformed itself into a salad bar accepting only cryptocurrency as payment, and began looping an annoyingly repetitive tune (yes, you know which one), chances are high you’d avoid it altogether—unless perhaps you’re an avid Imagine Dragons follower fond of salads and digital currency. This scenario somewhat mirrors what’s currently happening at Tesla.

Tesla is currently experiencing a mass departure of customers. New data reveals this trend: Edmunds Sure thing! People are departing from the fleet at an unprecedented rate, with trade-ins surging by 250% compared to last year’s first quarter. Just to be clear, that figure is indeed 250%.

This indicates that an increasing number of Tesla owners are opting to replace their previously cherished electric vehicles with different models. Data shows that Tesla trade-ins accounted for 1.4% of all Model Year 2017 and newer cars traded in during the recent period. While this percentage may appear small initially, it’s important to consider that this rate was only 0.4% back in March 2024, marking a significant rise of 250% when compared year over year.

Therefore, when considering the broader picture, we might not see a vast sea of Teslas inundating the used-car market. However, this steady flow of vehicles has diminished to more of a sparse stream. Despite this reduction, the high number of trades-ins reveals insights into how Tesla is perceived within the American automotive landscape—needless to say, these perceptions aren’t uniformly positive.

"As Brand loyalty becomes more uncertain due to factors like Elon Musk’s growing role in government, worries about Tesla vehicle depreciation, and higher presence in key metropolitan areas causing some long-term owners to feel less connected with the brand, " stated Jessica Caldwell. Edmunds The head of insights stated, "'As there are now more Teslas on the roads than at any time before, the brand’s original prestige might be diminishing for certain early buyers who previously valued these cars as symbols of status.'"

Edmunds ' data shows that considerations for car shoppers looking at a Tesla as their next new vehicle purchase fell to just 1.8% in February, the lowest point on record since October 2022. For context, the brand peaked in November 2024 right around the U.S. presidential election. Since then, but buzz has dimmed and that's showing in shopping behavior.

New Teslas are also being considered much less often when comparing options. Among those who still include Tesla in their selection process, the model’s position within that group appears to have dropped as well. This decline is particularly noticeable for what has traditionally beenTesla’s strongest offering—their core models. Model Y ) which is now being overtaken by comparable electric vehicles like the Ford Mustang Mach-E , Hyundai Ioniq 5 , Kia EV6 and Kia EV9, according to Edmunds .

Should this not be sufficient to persuade you, General Motors wishes to weigh in as well. According to an interview with InsideEVs, Chevrolet stated that Teslas accounted for 11% of all trade-ins received when customers opted for their electric vehicles in March.

The figure might increase further as more Teslas get older. According to predictions made by Edmunds, Tesla may face an unexpected challenge when owners finish paying off their loans and begin seeking options from competing manufacturers instead.

As things stand, numerous buyers lack the financial means to promptly replace an acquired automobile—particularly within the current landscape where pre-owned electric vehicles experience substantial devaluation relative to internal combustion engine equivalents," Caldwell stated. "In contrast with changing phone models or altering media platforms, trading in a car constitutes a considerable economic choice; consequently, even those who feel let down by Tesla will probably retain their cars due to practical constraints.

Interestingly, the secondary market seems to remain untouched for the time being. solely for the brief period Edmunds reports that there hasn't been a significant change in the prices or demand for Tesla vehicles in the pre-owned car market. However, this might simply reflect the time lag between when these cars leave their original owners and when they appear on dealerships' lots.

Could things change as Musk prepares to depart from D.C. ? Of course, though this remains uncertain. The brand has already suffered harm, which can be seen from global protests and vandalism against Tesla vehicles , Superchargers , and showrooms How the brand plans to make a comeback remains uncertain.

More EV Sales News

• U.S. Electric Vehicle Sales Increased by 11% in Q1. Tesla Experienced an 9% Decline
• Polestar Returned with Renewed Vigor in Q1
• GM's Top-Selling Electric Vehicle Might Surprise You
• Ford's Electric Vehicle and Hybrid Sales Rise Sharply in Q1 Before Tariff Confusion